← All games

Athletics @ Phillies

Athletics
19
Final
Phillies
Tue, May 5, 2026, 6:40 PM ET · MLB
Closing · ML +180 · SPR -1.5 · O/U 9

Archived game: the closing market as it stood at kickoff, kept permanently at this URL. Live odds, picks and the confluence table only run on games still on the slate.

Matchup summary

Final: Phillies beat the Athletics 9-1 at home. The market closed with Athletics at +180 on the moneyline and the total at 9. The closing betting splits (tickets vs money), the opening line and the movement into kickoff are below.

Market data captured (closing state as of ) · source: Action Network's closing consensus for this game · permanent record at this URL

More on this matchup: Athletics betting trends · Phillies betting trends · all MLB games

Athletics vs Phillies betting splits

Where was the money on Athletics vs Phillies?

MarketSideTicketsMoneyClosing line / odds
SpreadAthletics28%12%+1.5 (-115)
Phillies72%88%-1.5 (-104)
TotalOver80%82%O 9 (-120)
Under20%18%U 9 (-100)
MoneylineAthletics16%22%+180
Phillies84%78%-219

72% of spread tickets and 88% of spread money were on the Phillies, so the average Phillies bet was larger than the average Athletics bet.

80% of total tickets and 82% of total money were on the over, so the average over bet was larger than the average under bet.

84% of moneyline tickets and 78% of moneyline money were on the Phillies, so the Phillies drew more tickets than money and the average Athletics bet was larger.

Line movement

What was the closing line for Athletics vs Phillies?

MarketOpeningClosingMove
Spread (Phillies)-1.5-1.50
Total8.59+0.5

The Phillies opened -1.5 and closed -1.5: the spread has not moved.

The total opened 8.5 and closed 9, a 0.5-point move toward the over.

Why the line moved

Why did the Athletics vs Phillies line move?

The spread did not move from its opening number (Phillies -1.5) even with 88% of the spread money on the Phillies. The total moved 0.5 points toward the over (8.5 to 9), the side holding 82% of the total money and 80% of the tickets, so the line and the money went the same way. Splits describe where the money sits, not what will happen.

Splits describe where the money sits, not what will happen; there is no historical dataset for this sport yet.

Read more

Athletics vs Phillies Final Score, Closing Odds & Betting Splits — May 5, 2026 | Locksmith